Mom is furious after teacher embarrasses her 7th grader in front of classmates by forcing her to apologize publicly for being “bossy” during a group project

Author image for Etai Eshet
Etai Eshet • Editor
Feb 14, 2026 4:00 PM EST

We should all appreciate (most) teachers, and most of us do. That is, as long as they act like teachers, the ones that are authority figures, not reality TV judges for pre‑teens.

A middle schooler in a gifted magnet program gets roped into a group project that ends up landing almost entirely on her shoulders. She organizes the work spells out tasks for her teammates and keeps nagging them to contribute.  One girl does a handful of images another throws in a few sources and the rest of the heavy lifting becomes her full‑time gig.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • Female teacher standing beside a flip chart, explaining lesson objectives while teaching children in a classroom setting.
    via Centre for Ageing Better

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Teacher shamed my 7th grader in front of her classmates, and I'm seething. Am I overreacting?

    To start with, I respect teachers, and the work they do is amazing and very, very difficult.
    via CrowRoutine9631

  • So, while most teachers deserve our utmost respect, some, like the one in this story deserves something else altogether if you ask me. But I’ll leave it at that and let you decide what that thing would be after you read this mother’s story.

  • I couldn't do it. If I find out that one of my kids has been ride or disrespectful in school, they have to write an apology letter, and there are other consequences at home (my 5th grader is in trouble as we type for disrupting their class).
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • I put this here to say that this isn't about teachers in general. I have just come to seriously dislike this one teacher and right now I'm furious and loaded for bear.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • There have been issues with this teacher before that I'm not going to get into, and it's not just my kid.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • It's \all\ the kids. I even googled her and found identical complaints about her teaching from when she used to teach high school (she's inconsistent, dishonest, gave the literal same assignment a C one week and an A the next when a kid handed it in twice in a row because her grades were so arbitrary and divorced from effort, loses kids' work and then blames the kids, etc.).
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Elementary school students working together at a classroom table, smiling girl raising her hand while classmates write and draw on paper during group activity.
    via Getty Images For Unsplash+

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • This is also not about that. This is about what happened with my kiddo's group project, and how her teacher shamed her in front of her classmates today.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • I'm not going to write the whole d in story again (I just spent three hours going through the version history of their group google doc and typing up a timeline for when I go in and talk to this teacher and the principal tomorrow), so I'm just going to copy and paste the timeline I already wrote, with all names changed.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • This happened during a whole-floor celebration at the end of the day, so the kids were free to wander around the entire middle school (the top floor of the magnet school for gifted kids).
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • * Project was assigned in November. * Starting at the beginning of January, Kiddo began to ask her groupmates to contribute.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • * She asked them at least two times a week. * She laid out each step that they could do to help.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Alt text: Female teacher writing on a classroom chalkboard during a lesson, standing at the front of a school classroom with sunlight streaming through curtains.
    via Kateryna Hliznitsova

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • * Other Friend was glad for the guidance. Former Friend appears to have told Ms. Smith that this was bossy.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • * Last week (Thursday/Friday?), Former Friend ran crying from the seminar room. * Kiddo: "Ms. Smith, my other groupmates haven't been working." * Ms.
    via CrowRoutine9631

  • When one of the group members complains that she is bossy the teacher immediately sides with the complainer. She does not ask the student for her side she does not check the version history of the Google Doc she does not even pretend to look at the evidence. She just builds a story in her head and sticks with it.  

  • Smith told Kiddo that "Former Friend had to edit your mistakes. You've been bossy and taking charge of this project in a way that hurts the other people, that doesn't let anybody else work." Kiddo says, "She basically just brushed me off," and believes Ms.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Smith developed this point of view after Former Friend complained to Ms. Smith, but does not know for sure that this happened.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • school stundent standing at a green classroom chalkboard, turning to speak with two other students during a lesson.
    via Kateryna Hliznitsova For Unsplash+

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • * Ms. Smith did not ask Kiddo any questions. * Ms. Smith did not check the edit history.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • * Never, at any point, did Ms. Smith inquire about Kiddo's experience with this project. * * Tuesday: During the party at the end of the day, Kiddo was in Ms.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Smith's space. * Ms. Smith said, "I'm giving out candy to whoever was nice to me." * Everybody else got candy.
    via CrowRoutine9631

  • Then the floor party happens. The kids are wandering around loose the teacher is doling out candy like it is a loyalty program. She says she will only give candy to the students who were nice to her. Every kid who walked into the room at some point grabs a piece except the overworked one. She goes up and tries to join the fun and the teacher tells her in front of five to ten classmates that she owes someone an apology. She does not know who that is.

  • * Kiddo went up and asked for a piece of candy. * Ms. Smith said, "You owe someone an apology." Five to ten other kids heard Ms.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Smith say that. * Kiddo tried to apologize to Uninvolved Third Party. * Ms. Smith said, "You owe Former Friend an apology." * Kiddo asked why.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • * Ms. Smith didn't explain, and Kiddo * left. Kiddo was the only kid who didn't get candy.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • To be clear, my review of the entire version history of their google doc demonstrates that Kiddo told me the truth: she did pretty much all the work on this project.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Former Friend contributed a couple sources, and maybe ten images, and also frequently deleted and then repasted work that Kiddo did, maybe to make it look like that work should be attributed to them?
    via CrowRoutine9631

  •  The teacher names the girl who cried about being bossed around and the student is left standing there with no explanation. She is told she has to apologize to that girl in front of the class like it is a public reset button for middle school drama. She walks away empty‑handed while everyone else leaves with candy.  

  • Other Friend contributed a few images. It was an involved history research project with a good amount of writing and an annotated bibliography.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • I heard about this, and immediately messaged the teacher, the principal, and the school director (don't ask) to tell them that I'm coming in tomorrow to talk.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • The kids don't have school; the teachers are prepping for parent teacher conferences. My points tomorrow are the following: 1.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Ms. Smith took Former Friend's side without asking Kiddo for her side, and without looking for objective evidence.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • 2. Unless a student is currently disrupting the class, it is inappropriate to shame a pre-teen in front of her classmates.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • 3. Requiring one student to apologize to another in front of a bunch of other kids is for kindergartners.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • It's even less appropriate for 7th graders if it's for a behavior the teacher has neither witnessed nor verified.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • 4. Ms. Smith should have limited any consequences to a) a private conversation with both students, and b) grades, not public shaming.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • 5. The whole "you can have candy if you've been nice to me" is wildly inappropriate, independent of everything else.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Just imagine if a male teacher had said that, how bad the optics would be. Am I right to be angry about this?
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • I think it's just mortifying for a teen or pre-teen, whose entire personality is based on what other people think of them, to be embarrassed like that in front of their peers.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • That would have been bad enough even if the teacher were correct about her beliefs about how the group project went down.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • In this case, she was both cruel and objectively, verifiably wrong. So, am I overreacting? I'm calming myself down so I can be effective and not råde tomorrow, but at this moment, I'm ready to slash some tires and break some knee caps.
    via CrowRoutine9631

  • So what does this one teacher deserve? 

  • I'm furious.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Same-Department8080 NOR. No advice but how does your kid want to you to handle? Get involved or stay out? Follow their lead
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply She wanted me to stay out before, when her groupmates weren't helping with the project. We talked it all the way through, and I stayed out. But she's ready for me to intervene with this teacher.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Capable_Dark_6177 I absolutely agree with this. Cause like OP said this kid's entire identity is based off of what other kids think about them and if you get too involved, you don't want to embarrass your kid even more. It's kind of one of those lose lose situations. So I would absolutely talk to kiddo first and see how they wanna go about it. And if your kids all in then Momma bear it is.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply That was the first thing I did. I even got her permission to call my parents about it, because I wanted their advice.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • General-Carrot6407 NOR, I'm a middle school teacher and this behavior is not okay. Giving every kid candy but one, especially for the reason listed, is so infantile. She sounds like a nightmare to deal with. Good luck OP
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply I mostly haven't dealt with her. My kid gets good grades in her class (even if she hates every minute) and doesn't want to rock the boat. But now she's angry.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • General-Carrot6407 I don't blame her- I was the same way as a student and I'd feel so hurt and confused if this happened to me.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply I think she was really wounded. She's in a "I'm too cool for everything" phase that's kind of hilarious, but this really cut her to the quick. She was nearly crying when she told me about it after school today.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Norselrish So as a teacher you may know that a child coming home saying something like my teacher gave every kid in class a piece of candy except me is most likely a kid's exagerration and not really an accurate portrayal of the events.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply We went over it three times. The story was consistent. And it's just not the kind of thing my kid gets wrong or lies about. (And it fits pretty well in a larger pattern of this teacher's arbitrariness.)
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply I have no intention of talking to Ms. Smith about any of her other problems! Or mentioning those other reviews (those just confirm what we parents all suspected). I will go in with the version history summary (they can look at the whole thing themselves) and the little timeline of what happened when. I'm going to try to leave Former Friend out as much as possible. From my perspective, that's not my problem. And my kid asked me not to talk to their parents
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • Select_Draw3385 We had one teacher we had to intervene with and it still makes me mad to think about ten years later. And the lesson we learned? Nobody cared about our complained. So yeah. Fun times.
    via CrowRoutine9631
  • CrowRoutine9631 Original Poster's Reply That's something I'm a little worried about. The school hasn't been quick to correct any of her other issues. But I feel like this is so blatant and so wrong ... we'll see. Fingers crossed!
    via CrowRoutine9631

  • The mom finds out later and immediately dives into the Google Doc version history. She confirms that the teacher was wrong the student did almost all the work and one of the group members barely did anything and even tried to repaste her work to look like their own. The teacher never asked for proof never checked the data never treated a public shaming like the emotional grenade it is for a pre‑teen whose entire brain is wired to care what their peers think.  

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

mother teenagers teacher parenting raising teens daughter Terrible Teacher
Scroll Down For The Next Article